When demolition began on the 1890s Lutheran church at 2028-2033 N. Richmond St. late last year, the president of Logan Square Preservation pointed to the buildings around it. "It'll cost you $60,000 to tear down a two-flat on that block but you pay nothing to demolish a really prominent, noteworthy building," Andy Schneider told Block Club Chicago in December 2025. City permits for that site authorized four single-family homes with three-car garages for Mar Van Development LLC.
His comparison only works because the two-flat is the default building on a Logan Square block. If you are shopping for one so you can live in one unit and rent out the other, that matters more than any median price a portal shows you. A Logan Square two-flat is priced between two other buyers, an investor who values it as a rental and a buyer who values it as a future single-family house. From 2023 to 2025, the investor's share of these sales grew each year.
According to the DePaul Institute for Housing Studies Logan Square data portal, buildings with two to four units held 38.7% of all housing units in the community area in 2025. That's more than single-family homes at 14.1% and condominiums at 17.5%.
Only 184 of those buildings sold in calendar year 2025, down from 240 in 2024. The same IHS table shows 363 sales of 2-4-unit buildings in 2021 and more than 300 a year in most years from 2013 through 2016. You have to go back to 2009, when 181 sold, to find a year with fewer.
For a buyer, this is the first fact that matters. The building type that defines the neighborhood's streetscape came up for sale fewer than 200 times last year across all of Logan Square. That was split among two-flats, three-flats and four-flats, since IHS counts them together. When the building you want only comes along a few times a month, the price is set by whoever else is waiting for it.
IHS also tracks how many sales go to a business entity rather than an individual. For Logan Square 2-4-unit buildings, that share was 33.2% in 2025, up from 27.1% in 2024 and 22.7% in 2023. Business buyers took 11.4% of single-family sales and 2.1% of condo sales in Logan Square in 2025.
IHS defines a business buyer broadly. The category runs from small family landlords who buy through an LLC to large investment funds. So the figure doesn't mean Wall Street is buying up Logan Square. It means that in 2025, one in three of these buildings went to a buyer that was most likely pricing it on what the units can rent for.
That buyer looks at rents. When the conversion of the former Bethel International Full Gospel Korean Church at 2625 N. Talman Ave. won City Council approval in April 2025, the developers told Block Club Chicago they planned rents of $2,200 to $2,500 for a two-bedroom. Those are planned rents for new loft units with in-unit laundry, not observed rents in a vintage flat. Still, they show the kind of income an investor uses to justify a bid.
The second competitor is the buyer who looks at a two-flat and sees the single-family home it could become. In Logan Square, that buyer has had a strong reason to pay up.
DePaul's Cook County House Price Index for the second quarter of 2026, released October 15, 2026, puts single-family prices in its Logan Square/Irving Park submarket 283.9% above where they were in early 2000. Among City of Chicago submarkets, only Bridgeport/Lower West Side has risen more, at 322.0%. Logan Square/Irving Park is 74.8% above its bubble-era peak and rose 6.3% in the year through Q2 2026, against 5.7% for the city as a whole. The submarket's median single-family sale price was $800,000 from the third quarter of 2025 through the second quarter of 2026.
That index covers single-family homes only, and the submarket also includes Avondale and Irving Park. As a reference point, though, it shows why converting a two-flat into one house has paid off here. In September 2024, Ald. Jessie Fuentes described the pattern on the City Council floor, and Block Club Chicago reported that multifamily buildings converted into single-family homes in the area often sell for more than $1 million.
So a seller of a Logan Square two-flat can price against the rent math and the house-on-that-lot math, whichever comes out higher on that particular block. As a household, that higher number is the one you are bidding against.
The city has also been part of this market. In September 2024, City Council approved the Northwest Side Preservation Ordinance, which raised demolition surcharges for parts of the Northwest Side that include Logan Square. In 2025, the business-buyer share of Logan Square 2-4-unit sales reached 33.2%. The IHS data record who bought, not why they bought.
An owner-occupant comes to a Logan Square two-flat with an advantage neither competitor has, because you count both values at once. The rental unit carries part of the cost, and the owner's unit is worth something as your home. An investor gets only the rent. A buyer planning a single-family conversion gives up the rent to get a house.
NHS Chicago runs the Chicago Flats Initiative, a coalition of outreach, financing, policy and direct service groups that connects owners and renters of 2-4-unit buildings with mortgage and rental resources.
How you approach a given listing depends on which of those two values is setting its price. A two-flat on a block where new single-family homes have recently sold is priced off a different number than one surrounded by flats that have stayed rentals. Both trade in a market where fewer than 200 buildings with two to four units changed hands across the entire community area in 2025. Our earlier posts on what a two-flat is in Chicago and single-family or condo in Logan Square are also on the blog. Block-by-block context is on the Logan Square neighborhood page.
If you own a two-flat in Logan Square, or you're weighing an offer on one, it helps to know which buyer your building is likely to attract before you set a number. Start with an instant home valuation, then reach out to Haylee Stone to talk through how that number compares with the rent math and with recent single-family sales near you.
Haylee has a reputation for consistently carrying one of the most impressive luxury listing platforms in the marketplace. Contact Haylee today for a free consultation for buying, selling, renting or investing in Chicago.